Click here to see who won! The choice was tough as there were many very funny pictures. I had my wife, sister, and brother-in-law's help to choose the winner. So, congratulations to @FurBlaster on his great "Dumb and Dumber" poster recreation.
It came down to his, vicg27's "UFC & the City" creation, stuntmantravis's "pool monster" pic and Joey Shannon's "drinking downstream" pic.